Bakery
We offer scrumptious pies, gourmet cookies, fresh baked breads, and (of course) our award winning apple cider doughnuts! All treats are baked daily, on site, May - November, in a charming country kitchen that adjoins the farm market. You can smell the goodness as you shop!
Our baked goods are racking up the awards! We have been voted "Best Homemade Pies in the Hudson Valley" and most recently, "Best Apple Cider Doughnuts in the Hudson Valley" by readers and editors of Hudson Valley Magazine! Come see for yourself what all of the buzz is about!
Pies
Apple | Fresh Blueberry * |
Apple - Crumb | Lemon Meringue |
Apple - Raspberry | Mincemeat |
Apple - Raspberry - Crumb | Peach - Apple * |
Blueberry | Peach - Berry |
Blueberry - Crumb | Peach Melba * |
Cherry | Pecan |
Cherry - Raspberry | Pumpkin |
Banana/Chocolate/Coconut Cream | Pumpkin Almond |
Coconut Custard | Raspberry |
Five - Star | Strawberry Rhubarb |
* Pies are only available during peach and blueberry season, when fresh produce is available.
Gourmet Cookies
Anise Toast: An Italian Favorite! | Traditional Molasses Cookies: Sweet and extra soft. |
Beverly’s Rugelah: A tasty treat with afternoon tea! Made with coconut, walnuts, and homemade jam. |
Coldspring Oatmeal Raisin: A timeless classic.
|
Chocolate Mountains: Deep chocolate drop cookie, perfect for chocolate lovers!
|
Pecan Puffs: A light flaky pecan treat, rolled in powered sugar that will melt in your mouth!
|
Libby's Chocolate Chippers: A twist on traditional chocolate chip with walnuts. Perfect with a tall glass of milk. |
Peanut Butter Kisses: A crunchy peanut butter cookie topped with a Hershey’s Kiss.
|
Beverly's Cranberry Pistachio Biscotti: Delicious with a cup of coffee!
|
“S” Cookies: An traditional Italian recipe served in our family with Espresso coffee.
|
Deluxe Sugar Cookies: A Tantillo family favorite! In a variety of holiday shapes. |
Scandinavian Almond Bars: Made with almond filling, and decorated with sliced almonds.
|
Hazelnut Shortbread Sticks: Ground hazelnuts mixed into the dough – Light and flaky.
|
Spritz Cookies: A light crispy butter cookie.
|
Linzer Cookies: A shortbread cookie, nestled around Tantillo’s homemade jam. |
Triple Threat Choco-Cran Oatmeal: Chunks of fresh cranberries and a variety of chocolate chips dress up this classic for the holidays.
|
Aunt Nancy's White Chocolate Cherry Chunkies: A delicious drop cookie.
| Brian's Birthday Cookies: A log cookie for all celebrations! |